The best toasters of 2026
Six toasters the careful testers rate, from a $60 workhorse to a glass-walled long-slot, and who each one suits.

This page has affiliate links: if you buy through one, we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
No toaster is perfect every time: America’s Test Kitchen, who retested a full line-up in November 2026, found most brown unevenly from edge to edge. The good news is that the most even toaster in their test is also one of the cheapest.
We compared what America’s Test Kitchen, Reviewed, Taste of Home, Food Network and others found, and picked the six worth your counter space. Specs are the makers’ or the testers’ measurements.
Our picks at a glance
| Product | Best for | Slots | Typical price | Settings | Where to buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GE 2-Slice Toaster (G9TMA2SSPSS) | Even toasting on a budget | 2 wide | About $60 | Bagel, frozen | |
| Magimix Vision Toaster (11526) | Artisan loaves, and watching your toast | 1 long slot | Not stated | Large stop button | |
| Breville Die-Cast 2-Slice Smart Toaster (BTA820XL) | Gadget lovers who want control | 2 | About $200 | Bagel, defrost | |
| Cuisinart 2-Slice Compact Toaster (CPT-122) | Small kitchens | 2 | About $56 | Bagel, reheat, defrost | |
| Breville ‘A Bit More’ 4-Slice Toaster (BTA730XL) | Long slices for a household | 2 long (4 slices) | About $120 | 5 shades | |
| Smeg 2-Slice Retro Toaster (TSF01) | Style-first kitchens | 2 | About $230 | Bagel, defrost, reheat |
Best for most people: GE 2-Slice
America’s Test Kitchen named the GE its best conventional toaster for 2026: even white bread and bagels in under two minutes, for about a fifth of the price of their top pick. Reviewed also liked its sturdy build and even toast. The catch: English muffins sit low and are fiddly to retrieve.
GE 2-Slice Toaster (G9TMA2SSPSS)
Best for: Even toasting on a budget
An affordable stainless two-slicer that America’s Test Kitchen names its best conventional toaster for 2026.
- Slots
- 2 wide
- Typical price
- About $60
- Settings
- Bagel, frozen
- Size
- 11.2 × 6.9 × 7.6 in
Pros
- Toasts evenly and consistently
- Wide slots fit bagels
- Simple dial controls
- Medium toast in under 2 minutes
Cons
- English muffins are hard to fish out
- Sides and top get hot
- Takes fewer bread shapes than long-slot models
Best long-slot: Magimix Vision
The Magimix was America’s Test Kitchen’s top toaster overall. Glass walls let you stop it at exactly the shade you want, it averaged 1 minute 25 seconds for medium toast, and the outside stayed cool. Settings past the middle of the dial run hot, so start lower than you think.
Magimix Vision Toaster (11526)
Best for: Artisan loaves, and watching your toast
A long-slot toaster with glass walls, America’s Test Kitchen’s top toaster overall for 2026, at a premium price.
- Slots
- 1 long slot
- Settings
- Large stop button
- Walls
- Glass
Pros
- Even colour on most settings
- Glass walls let you watch the toast
- Takes a wide range of breads
- Outside stays cool
Cons
- Settings past the middle of the dial run hot
- Expensive
- Happiest with thick, moist breads
Best for control: Breville Die-Cast Smart
Reviewed called the Breville its best two-slice toaster for its build and motorised controls, and Taste of Home liked the progress bar. America’s Test Kitchen still recommends it but saw pale spots, so it isn’t the evenness champion its price suggests.
Breville Die-Cast 2-Slice Smart Toaster (BTA820XL)
Best for: Gadget lovers who want control
A motorised two-slicer with Lift and Look and A Bit More buttons. Testers like the build; not all found it even.
- Slots
- 2
- Typical price
- About $200
- Settings
- Bagel, defrost
- Size
- 11 × 6.8 × 7.8 in
Pros
- Solid, high-quality build
- Motorised lowering, with Lift and Look and A Bit More
- A progress display shows how far along the toast is
Cons
- Expensive for a pop-up toaster
- America’s Test Kitchen saw pale spots
- Taste of Home found it slower
Best budget compact: Cuisinart CPT-122
Reviewed’s best-value pick toasts fast and evenly in a small footprint. Its narrow slots are the trade-off: thick bagels and muffins are a squeeze.
Cuisinart 2-Slice Compact Toaster (CPT-122)
Best for: Small kitchens
An inexpensive, compact two-slicer that Reviewed picks as the best value for fast, even toast.
- Slots
- 2
- Typical price
- About $56
- Settings
- Bagel, reheat, defrost
- Size
- 11 × 6.5 × 7.2 in
Pros
- Low price
- Fast, even toasting
- Compact and good-looking
Cons
- Light build
- Narrow slots struggle with thick bagels and muffins
Best four-slice: Breville ‘A Bit More’
Reviewed gave its 4-slice Editor’s Choice to this long-slot Breville for even bread and bagels. America’s Test Kitchen was less impressed on a retest, and the top setting is close to burnt, so stay in the middle of the dial.
Breville ‘A Bit More’ 4-Slice Toaster (BTA730XL)
Best for: Long slices for a household
A long-slot four-slicer with A Bit More and Lift and Look. Reviewed rates it highly; America’s Test Kitchen less so.
- Slots
- 2 long (4 slices)
- Typical price
- About $120
- Settings
- 5 shades
Pros
- Even toast and bagels in Reviewed’s tests
- Long slots fit artisan slices
- Lift and Look and A Bit More buttons
- Quick
Cons
- Shallow slots
- The top setting comes out nearly burnt
- Did worse on America’s Test Kitchen’s retest
Best looking: Smeg 2-Slice Retro
Reviewed and Food Network found the Smeg toasts evenly, and it comes in many colours. America’s Test Kitchen found it slow and uneven at times, and it has no lift lever. Buy it for the look, knowing the GE toasts as well for a quarter of the price.
Smeg 2-Slice Retro Toaster (TSF01)
Best for: Style-first kitchens
A 1950s-style two-slicer in many colours. Testers love the look but find it pricey, and some found it slow.
- Slots
- 2
- Typical price
- About $230
- Settings
- Bagel, defrost, reheat
- Size
- 12.2 × 7.7 × 7.8 in
Pros
- Distinctive retro design in many colours
- Even toast in Reviewed’s and Food Network’s tests
- Reheat, defrost and bagel settings
Cons
- Expensive for a pop-up toaster
- No lift lever, and the outside gets hot
- America’s Test Kitchen found it slow and uneven at times
Sources
What each publication found, in our words. Follow the links for their full tests.