GE 2-Slice Toaster review: the even-toasting bargain

America’s Test Kitchen’s best conventional toaster costs about $60. Here’s what testers found, and who should buy something else.

An illustration of a two-slot steel toaster with toast popping up

This page has affiliate links: if you buy through one, we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.

Expensive toasters promise smart features; this one just toasts evenly. In America’s Test Kitchen’s November 2026 test it browned white bread and bagels evenly in under two minutes, and it costs about a fifth of their top pick.

GE 2-Slice Toaster (G9TMA2SSPSS)

Best for: Even toasting on a budget

An affordable stainless two-slicer that America’s Test Kitchen names its best conventional toaster for 2026.

Slots
2 wide
Typical price
About $60
Settings
Bagel, frozen
Size
11.2 × 6.9 × 7.6 in

Pros

  • Toasts evenly and consistently
  • Wide slots fit bagels
  • Simple dial controls
  • Medium toast in under 2 minutes

Cons

  • English muffins are hard to fish out
  • Sides and top get hot
  • Takes fewer bread shapes than long-slot models

What testers liked

  • Even toast. America’s Test Kitchen and Reviewed both found consistent, even browning, the hardest thing for a toaster to get right.
  • Wide slots. Bagels fit, and the bagel setting toasts the cut side.
  • Simple. A dial and a few buttons, nothing to learn.

What to know first

  • Small items sit low. Reviewed found English muffins don’t pop up far enough to grab easily.
  • It gets hot. The sides and top warm up, so keep it away from the wall.
  • Two slots only. For long artisan slices, a long-slot model like the Magimix Vision fits better.

Who should buy it

Anyone who makes toast or bagels most mornings and wants it even without paying for features. If you need four slices at once, see the four-slice picks in the best toasters of 2026.

Sources

What each publication found, in our words. Follow the links for their full tests.