How to choose a toaster
Slots, speed, evenness and settings: what matters, what doesn’t, and how much to spend.

A toaster has one job, and most do it unevenly. America’s Test Kitchen found no toaster perfect every time in its 2026 test. Here’s what separates the good ones, drawn from what the testers measured.
1. Evenness matters most
Look for even browning on both sides and the same result batch after batch: that’s what Reviewed weights most. Reviewed also notes that quartz heating elements heat faster and more evenly than coils.
2. Pick slots for your bread
- Bagels and thick slices: choose wide or extra-wide slots. Narrow compact models struggle with thick bagels.
- Artisan loaves: a long-slot toaster. America’s Test Kitchen says slots should be at least 10 inches long and 5 inches deep.
- Small items: a high-lift lever or a Lift and Look button makes English muffins easier and safer to retrieve.
3. Two slices or four?
A two-slice or compact model suits small counters. Four-slice models suit bigger households; get one with separate controls for each side (Food Network’s advice).
4. Speed and power
A good toaster makes medium toast in two minutes or less, per America’s Test Kitchen; toaster ovens brown evenly but take over five. Two-slice toasters typically draw 800 to 1,500 watts, and four-slicers around 1,400.
5. Settings worth having
- Bagel: toasts the cut side and warms the crust. Without it, put bagels in cut side in.
- Defrost: for bread straight from the freezer.
- A removable crumb tray: crumbs left inside can smoke and taste off, so pick one that slides out smoothly.
6. How much to spend
Taste of Home’s rough guide: under $100 for the basics, $100 to $200 for better build and more control, $200 and up for premium materials or smart features. Our best toasters pick is about $60.
Keeping it clean
Unplug it and let it cool, empty the crumb tray and wipe the outside with a damp cloth. Never submerge a toaster or put it in a dishwasher.