Toaster, toaster oven or air fryer: which do you need?
Three appliances that overlap. A plain guide to which one suits how you cook.

They all heat bread and crisp food, so it’s easy to buy the wrong one. The short answer: a toaster for toast, a basket air fryer for crisp food, and an air fryer oven if you want one machine for both and have the counter for it.
Choose a pop-up toaster if…
- You make toast or bagels most mornings: a good toaster makes medium toast in under two minutes, toaster ovens take over five (America’s Test Kitchen).
- Counter space is tight.
- You want to spend under $100. Our top toaster is about $60.
Choose a basket air fryer if…
- You want crisp fries, wings and vegetables fast: drawer fryers gave America’s Test Kitchen its best results.
- You cook for one to four people (a 5- to 6-quart basket suits most homes).
- You don’t need it to toast bread.
Choose an air fryer oven if…
- You’re replacing a toaster oven and want air frying too.
- You cook in 9 × 13 pans or for a crowd.
- You have about 22 inches of counter and don’t mind preheating.
Our picks for each
The best toasters of 2026, the best air fryers of 2026 and our Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro review.